Hell Hath No Fury Like A Customer Scorned


I walked past this vehicle in the street the other day and it got me to thinking about Detractors – how could it not? The owner of this vehicle was clearly so upset at the breakdown of trust between them and the brand that they were willing to risk the resale price of the car just to let other owners know about their experience.

On the scale of Detractor-ness (yes I just made that word up) this isn’t even that drastic. I’ve written in the past about customers who took extraordinary action against companies after being left frustrated by their lack of service. In the automobile industry in Australia, though, consider the story of Ashton Wood who preferred to destroy his $49,000 car with which he’d had 22 separate issues rather than on-sell it to someone else. Or Teg Sethi who spent $8,000 to make a rap video denouncing the manufacturer after his $60,000 vehicle was beset with problems.

The average person won’t go to the lengths these two gentlemen did to get their point across. They may put a sign on the back of their car but chances are they’re much more likely to take their grievance online.

Harvard Business Review research from July, 2010 found that 48% of customers who had a negative experience told 10 or more others. At that time, there were about 500 million Facebook subscribers and 40 million active monthly users on Twitter. Those numbers today are 1.6 billion (over 3x) and 310 million (almost 8x) respectively. I think it’s fair to say that the “10 or more others” are probably now more like 30 or more. In an age when customers can quickly and easily reference one another through the likes of social media, review websites and forums, Detractors have effectively been handed a megaphone.

According to a Nielsen Global Trust in Advertising survey, the two most trusted forms of brand information are friends and family (92% of consumers) and online consumer opinions (70% of consumers). By taking their displeasure with a brand online, Detractors therefore have the potential to cause significant damage.

The implication for companies is that they need to have robust dispute resolution processes in place to stop Detractors becoming Active Detractors. This is especially so in industries with high Customer Lifetime Values like the automotive industry.

So what does this entail?

  1. Catch Detractors early. Implement a feedback program and place a strong emphasis on service recovery – contacting strong negative feedback providers within a few hours (at most!) to try to solve their issues.
  2. Train empathy. Empathy is a quality that is seriously lacking from today’s corporate world. Train your frontline staff to put themselves in your customers’ shoes. How would they feel in their position? What would they think was a fair outcome? If staff are finding it difficult to justify the company’s position, it’s time to change your position.
  3. Empower frontline staff with the authority to act. Let’s use the example of a customer calling a contact centre to ask for a refund of money well after the initial purchase. Consider these two scenarios: in the first, the agent must go to a superior for approval and takes a week to get back to the customer with an answer. In the second, the agent is empowered to give the customer a refund on the spot. Clearly the latter outcome is less likely to lead to that customer “going social” while they’re waiting for a response and may even turn them into a Passive or even a Promoter on the spot.
  4. Have rigorous processes in place to deal with customer escalations. In the previous example, it may have taken a week for the agent to get back to the customer because their superior was on leave. Ensure that the responsibility to handle customer complaints is always delegated to someone “on deck” and that all complaints are tracked and managed using a central database.

When the total cost of a Detractor is considered – the lost business of one customer and potentially many more – it makes good financial sense for companies to do what they can to avoid customers becoming frustrated, angry and active.

What actions have you taken after a poor customer experience? Did you get satisfaction from doing it?

ilcNpfG0Ben Motteram is the Principal at CXpert, a Customer Experience consulting company that helps their clients grow by placing the customer at the centre of everything they do. With over 20 years’ experience in customer service, Ben has been recognised many times for the thought leadership articles that are regularly published on his blog. Follow him on Twitter and LinkedIn for more awesome insights on everything to do with customer service, customer experience and employee engagement.

Share this post:

One comment

  • Great article.

    First I start with a polite letter stating the problem and also giving a range of suggestions of solutions to the problem. I also ask if they have a suggestion. If the company then begins to stall, lie and try to trick me then after a lengthy correspondence back and forth I post a complaint on Trustpilot. Then I make a giant sign and put it in my window. And I write to a TV station and I also take legal action. They should not get away with it. Why should big business with enormous profits cheat and get away with it?

    we should all complain when sold a lousy product. Otherwise it will never get better.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *